
Stones in Water
Donna Jo Napoli
New York: Penguin Books USA Inc., 1997
209 pages
"...to have you for a friend."
3.5/5
Summary: After being taken from a local movie theater—along with other Italian boys, including his Jewish friend—by German soldiers, Roberto is forced to work for the German war effort until he escapes into the Ukrainian winter, desperately trying to make his way back to Venice.
Going into this book, I knew that Italy was part of the Axis power of WWII. What I did not know was that children in Italy, Hungary, Romania and other Axis countries, boys under 18 too young to fight, were rounded up by German soldiers and placed in work camps. Stones In Water tells the story of two such boys, both Venetian, one Italian, one Jewish.
Roberto and Samuele are not only forced to work under appalling conditions with little nourishment and inadequate shelter but they must also work to keep secret the fact that Samuele is Jewish. One day after months of labour building the tarmac for planes to land, the boys are instructed to build an enclosure. Thinking that it is meant to keep in horses or other animals, Roberto is shocked to learn from Samuele that the people who were herded into the pen were Polish Jews. Fully and finally understanding the severity of their situation, Roberto—with Samuele's help—finds a way to help a girl and her smaller sister for a little while, giving each boy a renewed sense of purpose and strength of character.
Stones in Water is a compelling story of suffering and survival, heartache and hunger. It is also a book about how the bonds of friendship can help carry us through our most trying times.
Recommended reading for grades 5 and up!
Also reviewed by:
Anna of Diary of an Eccentric
* 'Stones in Water' is my 6th selection for the War Through the Generations WWII Challenge. *


